Frosty Gifts

Photo of Frosty Gifts252 Delaware Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Frosty Gifts

Frosty Gifts

Take home your very own “slice” of the island at Frosty Gifts. From the wacky to the adorable souvenirs are available for sale at Frosty Bar in downtown Put-In-Bay and on their website! From Golf Balls to Shirts there is something for everyone.

Frosty Gift Shop Particulars

Celebrate Frosty Bar, an island institution, and your love of all things Frosty with a t-shirt, beer koozie, or a baseball hat you can purchase at the gift shop. Grab one of their iconic “Sunday Funday” tees and wear to Frosty to celebrate the laid-back island Sunday lifestyle. They also sell several different Frosty logo tees including sizes all the way down to toddler size!

The Frosty Tervis tumbler is great to bring with you out on the boat to prevent any party fouls, and you can fill with your preferred beverage, hot or cold! The straw is handy, making it easy to sip from while on the go. You can’t leave the island without scoring one of their iconic Frosty Mugs. This is the fishbowl glass mug they use to serve up ice cold beer at the bar all summer long!

For your holiday needs, they also carry Frosty Bar Christmas ornaments. Remember the warm summer days when the snow is falling during the holidays. Gift certificates are also available, a perfect gift for an island first-timer or a seasoned regular!

A classic Frosty logo baseball cap is a great gift for anyone, big or small. The chino cap is available in several colors and has a great fit!

Frosty Bar Pizza

With their ice-cold beer served in those classic Frosty mugs and a mouthwatering menu, Frosty is a centrally located, fun-filled, gathering place on Put-In-Bay. Owned and operated by the Stoiber family, Frosty understands what it takes to make Put-In-Bay special. Located right at the center of Delaware Avenue, across from DeRivera Park, right in the middle of the action.

Plasma TV’s line the walls and play sports all day long. There is always a game of pool going on, and a DJ spins every weekend so you can dance the night away! This place is an island favorite, they even have a competitive fishing team.

Their backyard is an awesome place to spend the afternoon out in the sun with a cozy chair and bar games, just grab a beer and settle in. If you’re hungry you can easily order from the Frosty Pizza or Big Man’s Burrito Stand which specializes in overflowing burritos and delicious tacos. Open late into the evening, both offer to satisfy those cravings after a night of partying.

Frosty also serves a delicious breakfast with both weekday and weekend specials. Their menu is full of both savory and sweet dishes and don’t forget a classic brunch cocktail like a Bloody Mary flavored with spicy peppercorn or garlic herb!

Lunch and dinner continue into the evening with delicious and filling meals. Known best for their homemade pizza, the menu also includes salads and specialty sandwiches. Try one of their signature pizzas like buffalo ranch chicken, or the brie, chicken, and arugula. The garlic cheesy bread makes a great snack any time of the day! No matter how long you’re visiting the island, be sure to make a stop at Frosty Bar and grab a treasure at Frosty Gifts!

In the Frosty Gift Neighborhood

As you leave the Frosty Gift Shop, the Put-in-Bay Boat docks are directly across the street and are a great place to stroll along the waterfront and people watch.  On the left side of the docks near the Boardwalk Restaurant Complex, you will the Put-in-Bay Parasailing headquarters. This unique experience allows you to fly as high as 1000 feet above Lake Erie either solo or tandem with a friend. If a hand-dipped ice Cream cone sounds good DJ’s Ice Cream is located just around the corner where you can enjoy ice cream seated near a shady grapevine covered patio. You are just steps away from Put-in-Bay Golf Carts the island premiere golf cart rent agency. They rent hourly, daily or overnight!