Frosty Pizza

Picture of the Frosty Pizza restaurant Put-in-Bay252 Delaware Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456
Frosty Pizza & Bar

For over 60 years the Stoiber Family has operated Frosty Pizza & Bar located on the main strip in downtown Put-in-Bay. The ice-cold mugs of draft beer served up with piping hot pizza have become an institution and a family dining experience.

Frosty Pizza & Bar Particulars

The Frosty bar is open for breakfast, lunch, dinner and late-night dinners. One of the islands most popular breakfast locations begins serving at 7 AM. Midway thru the day the restaurant and bar changes over to the daytime menu with their pizzas, subs, and salads. The walls of the restaurant depict spoofs on well know pizza products and a good selection of big screen TV’s for watching your favorite sports broadcasts. On busy summer weekends, a DJ heats up the dance floor with popular tunes and a light show. Food is served until 1 AM so it’s a great location to grab a pizza or a little Tex Mex from the Big Man’s Burrito Stand located in the rear of the Frosty Bar.

Frosty Pizza & Bar Breakfast Suggestions

  • Mexican Skillet with Hash browns covered with chorizo spicy sausage, two eggs, and queso. Served with toast.
  • Cara Berry Oats with unsweetened vanilla almond milk, dried cranberries, sliced almonds, a touch of honey and granola on top
  • Breakfast Meatloaf Benedict
  • Mexican Skillet with Hash browns covered with chorizo spicy sausage, two eggs, and queso. Served with toast.
  • Eggs Benedict ( To DIE for)
  • Buttermilk, Pumpkin, Chocolate Chip and Whole Grain Pancakes

On weekends, early risers will be rewarded with quick seating and great food and service. Later in the morning when the crowds build, a short wait time can be expected. Their Bloody Mary’s can help the wait become more enjoyable! As you enter the Frosty Bar on the right side, a coffee station is set up where you can create your own much-needed cup of morning Java!

Frosty Pizza & Bar Lunch & Dinner Options

Many places serve pizza, but the Frosty Bar kicks it up a notch with their specialty pies. Just a few of our favorites are:

  • Triple Pepperoni Pizza
  • Buffalo Ranch Pizza
  • The Italian Meat Lover
  • Brie, Chicken & Arugula Pizza

All of these great pies are served to your table out of an old school stone deck oven and loaded with cheese. If you are in the mood for something other than pizza, no worries they have that covered too! Try one of their oven baked subs, salads or appetizers!

Frosty Bar Cocktail Highlights

Just on the other side of the dining room, the Frosty Bar serves up specialty cocktails and their famous iced Frosty mugs of beer. Pool tables give the bar a neighborhood feel and are quite active. A few of our favorites include:

  • Cafe Cooler
  • Spicy Peppercorn Bloody Mary
  • Beer-mosa (Shock Top Belgian White Ale and orange juice)
  • The Garlic Herb or Spicy Peppercorn Bloody Mary
  • Any of their Ice-Cold Frosty Mugs of Beer!

Centrally located in the heart of the village of Put-in-Bay, the Frosty Bar is a perfect location to pause your Put-in-Bay Shopping for a great lunch or dinner. They offer carryout service as well and just across the street is DeRivera Park, a perfect location for a family picnic. Speaking of family, this location also offers an economical Frosty Family Pizza special that includes pizza, breadsticks, and beverages! Inquire with your server on your next visit to Put-in-Bay!