Picture of the Subway Put-in-Bay272 Delaware Ave.
Put-in-Bay, OH 43456

Put-in-Bay Subway 

Everyone loves Subway. Located in the lobby of the Commodore Resort and right next to Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill, Subway on Put-in-Bay is fast, convenient, and as always fresh. It is the only franchise restaurant operation on Put-in-Bay.

Subway Particulars

The aroma of delicious, fresh baked bread is always the telltale sign Subway is nearby. The Commodore is located in the center of downtown Put-in-Bay on Catawba Avenue and features a sign for Subway on its facade, making it easy to find.

Subway is always the perfect mix of sustenance and value. They make the best sandwiches for lunch on the boat or a late night snack. Signature sandwiches, like the Meatball Sub, pack a powerful flavor punch while classics like the Turkey sub always satisfy.

Breakfast is served daily and there’s also a value menu available. They make sure to provide a range of healthy options like the light and tasty Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki. Subway salads are just as good as their subs! You can personalize your sub by creating your own with a large selection of fresh veggies, deli meats, and sauces.

Subway Catering

Put-in-Bay’s Subway also provides catering. For large groups, they make it easy with their party sub, sandwich platters, desserts, and drinks. Try out a boxed lunch from Subway the next time you head out on a fishing charter. A sub, bag of chips, and a cookie make the perfect treat to enjoy after landing that trophy catch on Lake Erie!

Subway Late Night and Pool Bar Eats

This Subway location is open late. Stop by after dancing at The Green Room at Mr. Ed’s or partying at one of the many downtown Put-in-Bay Bars. Once the sun sets, head to Mr. Ed’s Bar and Grill. This island favorite is always hopping with a full menu and a crazy list of live events all summer. Some of the best parties happen at Mr. Ed’s from the start of season Pajama Party to the Halloween Party and Costume contest!

The Green Room is the most exclusive nightclub on the island. Located on top of Mr. Ed’s, it provides amazing views, hot tracks, and cozy seating. Dance until the wee hours. Definitely, the most fun place to be on the weekends at Put-in-Bay!

In the Subway Neighborhood

A great place to enjoy a Subway is just up the street at the Perry’s International Peace Memorial. Their lushly landscaped grounds combined with a waterfront location make for a perfect backdrop for a picnic lunch. Equally as attractive for a picnic is the Scheff East Point Preserve located on the eastern side of the island. Be sure to stop by the sweetest bar of all, THE Candy Bar where all your childhood favorite and hard to find brands are sold.